• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

belgianwaffle

  • Home
  • About
  • Archives

LRB winner

3 September, 2006
Posted in: Reading etc.

And the winner is…

The panel* was very impressed with the level of all the entries, and congratulates  all who took part. Candidates might have scored higher marks for mentioning the Iraq war or the works of Jacques Derrida, but this did not detract from the generally high standard. Sadly, there can only be one winner, so here are the comments in reverse order.

In third place, Daddy’s Little Demon. A good piece which captured much of the LRB’s style – but failed somehow to convey the smugness of the original. For future reference, name-checking Derrida or Lacan would have carried more marks than Maslow, who is now seen as very pre-post-modern.

In second place, Disgruntled. The piece showed great self-confidence but was too short for the panel to judge whether the tone could be sustained over a longer composition. Also, although the use of the word “bildungsroman” greatly impressed the panel, a true LRB author could never begin a German noun with a lower-case letter: the pedantic urge would be too strong.

In first place, Heather. A fluid piece, effortlessly using many LRB favourites (like “signifier and signified” and “cultural paradigm”)  and most accurately capturing the spirit of the original. It may be asked whether Heather, like Disgruntled, should lose marks for spelling “zeitgeist” without a capital. However, the New Oxford Dictionary of English still treats “Bildungsroman” as a German word (with capital) while “zeitgeist” has now been naturalised long enough to be spelled without a capital. Therefore, the use of the word in an actual LRB article would spark a fruitful exchange of correspondence between lexicographers, Germanists and assorted pedants, which could spread over several subsequent issues of the Review. It can therefore be seen as the icing on the cake of this audacious effort.

The winner is Heather.

*Mr Waffle – who took a break from cleaning up vomit to write this – more of which anon.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Operaworks says

    4 September, 2006 at 11:07

    However, American usage might just allow non capitalisation.
    http://dictionary.reference.com/search?r=2&q=bildungsroman

  2. heather says

    4 September, 2006 at 12:46

    I would like to thank the distinguised panel and my fellow candidates for this life-changing opportunity. I am very excited.

    Ta.

  3. disgruntled says

    4 September, 2006 at 14:51

    Oooh, I think if the judging panel had thought I was using American usage I’d have been lucky to get third place …
    Damn, I’ll have to buy my own copy now. Although if it references Derrida too much I probably won’t bother. (not sour grapes at all. Not at all…)
    I hope the vomit wasn’t Mr. Waffle’s own

  4. Graubart says

    5 September, 2006 at 15:40

    What an impressive (though of course unsurprising) level of case-sensitivity throughout, reflected even in Operaworks’s reference, which not only respects German capitalisation rules in the etymology but even, remarkably, uses “protagonist” in its proper sense.

  5. Daddy's Little Demon says

    6 September, 2006 at 15:06

    sigh..

Primary Sidebar

Flickr Photos

IMG_4280
More Photos
September 2006
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930  
« Aug   Oct »
Tweets by Belgianwaffle

Categories

  • Belgium (141)
  • Boys (758)
  • Cork (186)
  • Daniel (514)
  • Dublin (402)
  • Family (546)
  • Hodge (44)
  • Ireland (761)
  • Liffey Journal (7)
  • Michael (506)
  • Miscellaneous (71)
  • Mr. Waffle (455)
  • Princess (983)
  • Reading etc. (539)
  • Siblings (164)
  • The tale of Lazy Jack Silver (18)
  • Travel (149)
  • Work (162)

Subscribe via Email

Subscribe Share
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy

© 2003–2021 belgianwaffle · Privacy Policy · Write